Home » Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel with Garlic Yogurt Sauce
Homemade sSoft and Delicious Authentic Falafel with homemade hummus and garlic sauce

Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel with Garlic Yogurt Sauce

Even if you’re not a falafel fan, you’ll love this Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel – a great vegetarian staple even meat lovers will enjoy! Falafel the way it should be…

Close up of homemade Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel

This soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel recipe is spot on. During the journey to refine this recipe, I’ve learned multiple things about how to make a desirable fluffy, tender, and moist falafel. Keep reading and you’ll learn everything that I have. And, if you’ve got more tips to make this even better, please reach out and let me know!

What is Falafel?

If you haven’t had it or don’t know anything about falafel, it’s Mediterranean/Middle Eastern street food, that’s naturally gluten free! In a nutshell, falafel is a combination of rehydrated chickpeas and/or broad beans, also known as fava beans, herbs, spices, and lemon juice ground together then deep fried. Good falafel hardly needs any extra sauce at all other than a little bit of tahini or hot sauce. Its origins generally are accredited to the Egyptian Copts approximately 1,000 years ago, but like with any good food, there are always naysayers.

If you’re like me, you’ve probably had plenty of bad falafel and a few good ones. It’s funny how the memory of a great falafel will give you hope when you order it in a new place, but then it quite often ends up being a dry lump of chickpeas. Falafel was usually a menu item I often ignored. But after going to a local joint called Jaffa Restaurant in Roswell, GA , I found one of the greatest falafels I’ve ever had and embarked on a quest of my own…

Bite of Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel with homemade hummus

Of course that new recipe idea went on the dry erase board with about 40 other potential candidates… That was until my wife brought home a falafel mix from Trader Joes! Normally I enjoy Trader Joe’s products, but after eating those, I realized I’d probably get more enjoyment eating the cardboard box they came in!

The Keys Are In The Chickpeas

Let’s start with the base of the recipe… No, not cardboard – but chickpeas!!! Dried chickpeas, not canned onesplease, do not use canned chickpeas or your falafel will turn to mush. Reason being, canned chickpeas are already cooked. Cooked chickpeas mean the starches within them have already bled out and now they’re too soft. Think about it, if you hold a canned chickpea between two fingers and press down, it turns to mush and mush is exactly what you’ll get. Those are great for making hummus, though!

Dried chickpeas are the one and only option (well, you can probably use fresh green chickpeas, but I have zero experience with that). First, start off with the oxymoron of fresh, dried chickpeas… The bag of dried ones accumulating dust in the back of your cupboard or the grocery store’s shelf can be used for a stew, but not for falafel. Over time, like anything, the chickpeas lose their ability to full absorb water – and the first step in this recipe is to soak the beans! After soaking for 12-16 hours, you want your chickpeas to double in size and be ready for the grind.

In regards to which chickpeas to buy, I generally use Goya or La Preferida brands. With that said, there are tons of brands such as Palouse proclaiming non-gmo, organic, heirloom, etc… I wouldn’t be surprised if they’re better, but I haven’t actually tried them. I’m a little falafeled out, but I’ll test these with my next batch.

I never thought I’d have this much to say on chickpeas.

Plated homemade Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel with homemade hummus, garlic sauce, and vegetables

Herbs Also Make Delicious Authentic Falafel

Next up on making a great falafel are the fresh herbs! You really can’t use too much of them. Avoid using dried herbs as they don’t have the same fresh vibrance. I used a mix of 50% parsley, 25% mint, and 25% cilantro in this recipe. Definitely keep mint lower in the ratio of herbs as it can be quite pungent and overpowering of the rest of the flavors. Also, considering that it’s all going to get liquified, feel free to leave the stems on.

To Deep Fry or Not To Deep Fry: That’s Not a Question

For this Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel, I recommend frying the falafel in oil. Yes, you can definitely air fry or bake them, but in my trials they come out a bit dry and not as crunchy on the outside. Another option is to form your falafel into patty shapes and pan fry it. Considering the increased surface area and heat, they take less time to cook than air frying or baking. That decreased cooking time also allows for the falafel to retain its moisture. But realistically, for that perfectly crisp on the outside and moist on the inside, I recommend you fry them in about a half inch of high heat oil (such as grapeseed or avocado oil) until brown, then flip them. The whole process takes about 5 minutes of frying.

Close up of opened homemade soft and fluffy falafel

Your falafel dough should come out very light and fluffy. You want your dough to be homogenous. If you’re seeing chunks of chickpeas, herbs, or onions, then keep on processing or blending until there are no more. The first time I made it, I was quite sure the dough would hit the oil and break apart. Fear not, the starches from the chickpeas act as a binder keeping it intact.

Emulsifying Your Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel

Let me tell you, blending or food processing the mix is a bit of a pain… Because you don’t mix in any liquids, you will have to take the cover off the processor and occasionally “unstick” the dough in the beginning. Once all the chickpea particles, herbs, and onion are small enough, the dough should almost blend through like a thick milkshake. One trick I found to somewhat alleviate the food processor traffic jams is to start by liquifying the herbs, garlic, onion, and lemon juice first, then adding the beans. It’ll help lubricate the chickpeas as they’re getting pulverized.

Falafel dough ready to fry in a Cuisinart Food Processor

You Don’t Need Big Balls

Another important trick I’ve learned is regarding the falafel size. You don’t want your falafel balls to be too large or the insides won’t cook all the way through. Keep each falafel ball to around 1.5 Tablespoons. This allows for the inside to cook just enough while allowing the outside to get that crisp texture. If your falafel balls are too large, you’ll get the crispness on the outside, but the inside will dry out before the center is fully cooked. I used a cookie dough scoop to keep the size and shape uniform, this Saebye Cookie Scoop Set on Amazon is perfect.

falafel with hummus

Tips and Tricks For Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel

  • Falafel is best fresh… I hate to tell you this, but reheated falafel isn’t nearly as exciting… But, if you’re really, really… and I mean really in a pinch, either bake it at 400°F in the oven for 6-7 minutes or airfry it for 3-4 minutes, don’t forget to give the falafel a spritz of oil before reheating.
  • Good News: Your uncooked falafel dough will keep for 3 days in the fridge! It could be longer, but I’ve tested it in up to three days and the dough was still fantastic.
  • The oil matters… You want the oil temperature to be minimally 350°F, but preferably closer to 375°F. With that said, it’s getting close to the smoking point of many oils. For that, I use a neutral high heat oil like grapeseed or avocado oil to avoid all the smoking and getting the most flavor
  • Call your gluten-free vegan friends over, because you FINALLY have something to serve them! Just don’t give them the garlic sauce, unless you use vegan mayo and yogurt.
  • Many recipes call for leavening ingredients such as baking soda or baking powder… If you’re looking for a bit more of a “muffin” texture, then go for it… But realistically, the best falafels are made without, trust me I made the mistake over and over again. I went back to Jaffa Restaurant in Roswell, talked with the owner and she let me in on her not-so-secret secret.

The Garlic Yogurt (Shawarma) Sauce with Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel

Yes, I know… I said that good falafel only needs a little tahini and hot sauce. That said, if you get a good falafel shawarma or wrap, it’s generally served with a yogurt garlic sauce. In my opinion, I like this as much, if not more than tahini and hot sauce! It’s fresh and garlicky with a bit of tang… What’s not to like?

Also, Check Out Some of Our Other Recipes!

Soft and Delicious Authentic Falafel

4.7 from 19 votes
Course: Snacks, Appetizers, Lunch, DinnerCuisine: Mediterranean


Prep time


Cooking time



An easy, delicious falafel recipe… Soft, moist, and crisp the way falafel should be.

Cook Mode

Keep the screen of your device on


  • 1 Lb Dried Chickpeas (Soaked for 12-14hrs)

  • 1-1/2 Cups Red Onion-Roughly Chopped (1 medium sized onion)

  • 3 Tbsp Fresh Garlic-Roughly Chopped (About 6-7 medium sized cloves)

  • 1/4 Cup Fresh Mint-packed

  • 1/2 Cup Fresh Parsley-packed

  • 1/4 Cup Fresh Cilantro-packed partial stems

  • 2 tsp Ground Coriander Seed

  • 1 tsp Ground Cumin

  • 1/2 tsp Black Pepper

  • 2 tsp Himalayan Pink Salt

  • 1/2 tsp Lemon Zest

  • 2 Tbsp Lemon Juice

  • Optional
  • 2 Tbsp Sesame Seeds (for coating)

  • Tahini (for dipping)

  • Hot Sauce (for dipping)

  • Garlic Yogurt (Shawarma) Sauce
  • 3/4 Cup Greek Whole Fat Yogurt

  • 2 Tbsp Mayonnaise

  • 2 tsp Fresh Garlic- Crushed

  • 1 Tbsp Lemon Juice

  • 2 tsp Apple Cider Vinegar

  • 1/2 tsp Himalayan Pink Salt

  • 1 tsp Granulated White Sugar (Optional)

  • Black Pepper- To taste (Optional)


  • Soak your dried chickpeas for 12-14 hours in room temperature water. (Do not try to speed the process up with boiling water, you’ll get the same results as using canned chickpeas.)
  • In a Food Processor or Powerful Blender, put in your herbs, garlic, lemon juice, and onion and blend to create a liquid base.
  • Add the strained chickpeas, spices, and zest to the blender/processor and emulsify your ingredients until they are thick homogeneous blend. You will most likely have to use a spatula a couple times to loosen up the ingredients, as there is little additional liquid.
  • Let your falafel dough rest for about 15 minutes to let the starches bind.
  • Frying
  • While waiting for the dough to setup, place about 2 Cups of Grapeseed or Avocado Oil in a medium sized pot and set on medium heat.
  • Once the oil has reached 350°F to 375°F scoop approximately 1.5 Tbsp balls of falafel dough. You can either dip or sprinkle them with sesame seeds, as desired. Then place the balls into the oil. Cook for approximately 3 minutes (or until golden brown), then rotate with a slotted spoon to cook the topside. Continue cooking for another 2-3 minutes and remove from the oil onto either a cooling rack or paper towel to absorb excess oil. You can fry multiple falafels at once, just don’t overcrowd the pot.
  • Continue until all your falafel dough is cooked and serve hot!
  • Air Fryer Method
  • On a parchment lined airfryer sheet, spray the parchment with your high heat oil (Grapeseed or Avocado).
  • Scoop 1.5 Tbsp balls of falafel dough and sprinkle/roll with the optional sesame seeds.
  • Place each falafel ball approximately 1/2 of an inch apart, then airfry for approximately 10 minutes at 375°F, then flip them for an additional 5 minutes.
  • Remove the falafel from the airfryer and serve hot!
  • Garlic Yogurt (Shawarma) Sauce
  • Combine all ingredients and mix!
  • Serve with just about anything, but especially shawarma, falafel, or vegetables!

Did you make this recipe?

Tag @cakesandcoriander on Instagram and hashtag it

Like this recipe?

Follow us @cakesandcoriander on Pinterest

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *