Home » Easy and Elegant Old Fashioned Fudge Pie
Olf Fashioned Fudge Pie with Strawberry on Top

Easy and Elegant Old Fashioned Fudge Pie

Occasionally, when we try a throwback recipe, we realize that we are not the only generation intimately familiar with outrageously delicious food. This Easy and Elegant Old Fashioned Fudge Pie is no exception. It is incredibly rich and chocolatey, with a velvety texture that melts in your mouth. The entire flavor is balanced by a light, homemade whipped cream frosting. The combination is as insanely good as it is simple.

Individual Plated Piece of Old Fashioned Fudge Pie with Strawberries on table with other plate

Where Does This Delicious Pie Recipe Hail?

When Stevens and I decided that we wanted to attempt a food blog, we both happened to be on an extended trip visiting our parents in Arizona. In that home, my mother has 2 giant books full of old family recipes, tried and true. My job was to go through them and pick out the best of the best. One of the items I came across was the original version of this Old Fashioned Fudge Pie. Where it came from, we weren’t completely sure but the recipe card said ‘to die for’. It was worth taking a shot…and it was a bullseye.

Whole Old Fashioned Fudge Pie

Is This Recipe Difficult or Time Intensive?

In a word, no. I have made this pie now about 6 times, and each time to rave reviews by family and friends. I’ve tried an entire host of different ways to make it. I have made it with a shallow pie crust and a deep dish pie crust. I’ve topped it with whipped cream, ice cream, fruit toppings and chocolate. They all turned out (surprisingly) delicious, but what I present here is the final version. It will satisfy the greatest chocolate craving! And there is an added bonus. This pie takes only 10 minutes to make both filling and topping and you don’t need any special tools to get it done.

The Best Pie to Make in a Pinch

I think one of the things I love about this pie is that the majority of ingredients are things that you can have on hand at all times. There are so many times when people come over last minute and I want to have a special dessert, but don’t have time to run to the store. I always keep extra butter in my freezer and like to have a few frozen pie crusts in there too. I also always have sugar, vanilla and (now that I’ve made this pie) about 4-5 good-quality chocolate bars on hand. I don’t always have heavy whipping cream for the topping, but I do usually have a can of whipped cream somewhere…or ice cream. To be completely frank though, this pie filling is so darn good, it doesn’t *really* need anything to accompany it.

Chocolate shavings with grater, strawberries and chocolate on table in front of pie.

Tips and Tricks for Making Easy and Elegant Old Fashioned Fudge Pie

  • If you are making it gluten free and don’t have a favorite pie crust, we really like this Wholly Gluten Free Pie Crust. My husband, Graham, took one bite (not knowing it was gluten free) and said, wow this is a GREAT pie crust!
  • To make this for a non-gluten free crowd, use your favorite pie crust and replace 1:1 Gluten Free Flour with regular white flour.
  • If you want to make this for a deep dish pie shell, double the filling ingredients (3 eggs, not 4) and up the cook time to 60 minutes. The pie crust may start to get too dark so check it around 30 minutes and tent-foil over the top of the pie to continue cooking without getting it too dark.
  • Don’t forget to pierce the crust with a fork before cooking. This helps it to stay down and not puff up and out.
  • When making the whipped cream, I prefer to use the whisk attachment on my immersion blender because it makes such quick work of it!
  • This pie filling does rise a little, but I haven’t had any problems with overflow. Just to be safe, I like to cook my pies on top of a foil-lined cookie sheet. Better safe than cleaning up a hot/sticky mess.
  • If the top of your pie is getting too dark for your liking, you can use a piece of foil to tent over the top. Just try to not have the foil touch the top of the pie because it will take some of the pie with it when you pull it off.

If you Like This, You Might Also Like

World’s Best Cheesecake on World’s Best GF Crust

GF Scrumptious Olive Oil Orange Cake

Gluten Free Decadent Chocolate Cake with Salted Browned Butter Frosting

Old Fashioned Fudge Pie

4 from 2 votes
Course: DessertDifficulty: Easy
Cook Mode

Keep the screen of your device on

Servings

8

servings
Prep time

30

minutes
Cooking time

40

minutes

Ingredients

  • 4 Ounces Above 50% cocoa chocolate bar (about 1 bar), Separated

  • 1/2 Cup Salted Butter (1 stick)

  • 3/4 Cup White Granulated Sugar

  • 2 Eggs, beaten

  • 1/8 Cup Gluten Free 1:1 Flour or White Flour (non gf)

  • 1 Frozen 9 inch Gluten Free Pie Crust *See Tips and Tricks for Suggestion

  • Whipped Pie Topping
  • 1 Cup Heavy Whipping Cream

  • 1 Tbsp Powdered Sugar

  • 1 tsp Vanilla

  • Strawberries – Optional for topping

Directions

  • Chocolate Fudge Pie Filling
  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Poke your pie crust all over with a fork. Once oven is preheated, place pie crust in oven for 10 minutes. Take out and set aside.
  • While pie shell is baking, melt butter in large microwave safe dish (about 45 seconds). Add 2 ounces of chocolate (about half a bar) and place back in microwave for 45 seconds, Stir until butter and chocolate are completely melted and combined together.
  • Add sugar to butter/chocolate mixture, and mix until completely combined. Add vanilla, eggs and mix well. Add flour and fold in until just combined. Pour filling into pie crust.
  • Place pie on top of a cookie sheet (for any potential overflow) and place in center rack of oven. Bake for 40-45 minutes or until pie looks set and doesn’t jiggle much when given a shake. Take it out and let cool completely. Below is pie after cooking without any topping.
  • Whipped Pie Topping
  • In large bowl, combine 1 cup heavy whipping cream, 1 Tbsp powdered sugar, 1 tsp of vanilla and beat until semi-stiff peaks form. Smooth whipped cream mixture onto the top of the pie.
  • Use remaining chocolate bar to decorate. I used a grater to grate some chocolate on top of the pie and then broke pieces apart to place on each piece before serving. Serve within the hour or place in refrigerator until ready to serve. Top with strawberries if desired. Enjoy!

Did you make this recipe?

Tag @cakesandcoriander on Instagram and hashtag it

Like this recipe?

Follow us @cakesandcoriander on Pinterest

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

*